item #2 · bbq
Claim 046414618-01 / 046414618-02 · Liberty Mutual
Facts
- Claimed Amount
- $517.00
- Brand
- Weber
- Model
- Genesis Silver B (6721501)
- Acquired Year
- 2005
- Enriched Slug
- weber-genesis-silver-b-bbq
- Original Brand
- Weber
- Original Model
- 2005 6721001 Genesis Silver B Propane, Black
- Original Qty
- 1
- Original Total Paid
- $505.18
- Pre Loss Purchase Date
- 2005-07-19
- Pre Loss Order Id
104-1800223-2241504- Pre Loss Asin
B000659KA0- Pre Loss Vendor
- Amazon.com
- Pre Loss Ship To
- Dan Sellars 507 2nd Street #4R Brooklyn NY 11215 (pre-2019 PA purchase; physically relocated to New Hope when household moved)
- Replacement Status
- not_yet
- Replacement Date
- # YYYY-MM-DD when item was replaced (if applicable)
- Replacement Brand
- Weber
- Replacement Model
- Spirit II E-310 3-burner
- Replacement Price
- $549.00
- Replacement Url
- https://www.weber.com/US/en/grills/gas-grills/spirit-series/spirit-ii-e-310/4501…
- Replacement Receipt
- # filename of paid receipt in 30-invoices/
- Liberty status
- ⏳
- Liberty Status Note
- Awaiting per-item parse of estimate w. contents - sellars.pdf (Liberty 1/13/2026 attachment).
- Dispute Status
- STRONG — $12 dollar variance vs $517 claim. Long ownership history (16y). Need to clarify with Liberty the Brooklyn ship-to + physical relocation narrative.
- Depreciation Withheld
- null # amount Liberty withheld (if any)
- Depreciation Recovered
- false # has the holdback been recovered?
Notes
**Weber Genesis Silver B Propane Grill, model 6721501, black** — three-burner gas grill, the workhorse mid-tier of Weber's outdoor cooking range. Photo composite shows: original Amazon Order Details screenshot dated 18 July 2005 ($489.99 + $26.18 shipping + $0.00 tax = **$516.17 total**, shipped to 6279 Greenhill Rd, New Hope PA); and a damage-state photo of the grill cabinet with its lid and side door partially intact but the body resting at an angle amid splintered yellow lumber and wood debris (the destroyed shed's wall framing). "16 years since July 2005" age stamp. **Weber Genesis Silvers are famously long-lived** — many still in working condition at 20+ years with periodic burner/grate replacements; depreciation should not assume short-cycle replacement. Claimed $517 matches the Amazon receipt ($516.17 rounded). [TBD: replacement status — has the grill been replaced or is it still standing as a damaged-but-perhaps-repairable unit?]